Month: May 2017

How passion preys on both sides of Trumpmania

Last week a conservative columnist for Bloomberg penned a rational and evidence-based article hoping to explain to President Donald Trump’s base exactly why some thinkers in the movement remain troubled by his many missteps. It was a complete waste of ink, of course, but Megan McArdle probably knew that before it was written. That was kind of the point of her argument. “The conservative voters who elected Donald Trump seem to feel especially betrayed when those who document his failures and violations are fellow conservatives. Like me,” she wrote, adding that Trump’s most ardent supporters instinctively push back on all criticism as “Trump Derangement Syndrome.” To the Trump believer, if anyone disagrees with something the president says or does, then they’re either an irrational hater, part of the loathed establishment, or propagating “fake news.” It’s the intellectual equivalent of sticking one’s fingers in their ears, closing their eyes and shouting “lalalala,” or of seeing enemies lurking in every shadow, even one’s own. While there are indeed haters and establishment powers and biased news outlets, they’re not everywhere. There are writers like Ben Shapiro and radio host Mark Levin whose conservative credentials and alliance to our movement are beyond question, yet who will criticize the president when necessary. To think that they’re somehow part of a liberal conspiracy is beyond reason. It’s crazy talk. Yet I’ve seen life-long friends within the conservative movement, friends who are politically educated and with considerable experience, suddenly become blind and deaf to Trump’s mistakes. If…

Are conservatives winning the culture war?

It’s been a quarter century since Pat Buchanan took the stage at the 1992 Republican National Convention and introduced the phrase “culture war” into our nation’s lexicon. “There is a religious war going on in our country for the soul of America,” Buchanan said. “It is a cultural war, as critical to the kind of nation we will one day be as was the Cold War itself.” The fire and brimstone tone of his speech embarrassed moderates within the party, but the truth of the matter is that Buchanan was, and remains, correct. We are certainly in a cultural war. One side faithfully adheres to the traditions that have made our nation great while the other wants to trade them for unproven fads. We’ve long told ourselves that, like the Roman Empire before us, the only way America could be defeated is from within. What else is “within” a country if not its culture, and what within a culture is more telling than what it considers virtuous? We’ve known this from our Founding. “While the people are virtuous they cannot be subdued,” wrote Sam Adams in a 1779 letter to a fellow Massachusetts patriot. “But when once they lose their virtue they will be ready to surrender their liberties to the first external or internal invader.” So if we are in a cultural war for the virtue of our nation – and indeed we are – we must, like every good battlefield commander, take a brutally honest assessment of the…

Will conservatives ever leave the Republican Party?

After the Republicans passed a spending bill that could have been authored by left-wing Democrats (and largely was, in fact), radio host Rush Limbaugh pointedly asked the vice president, “Why is anybody voting Republican, if this is what happens when we win?” I asked myself the same question last week as I walked the halls of Congress with my seven-year old daughter. We were visiting family and I took the opportunity to show her where I lived and worked years ago when I was a press secretary for then-Congressman Bob Riley and later as a Congressional liaison for President George W. Bush’s defense department. “I came here to change things,” I told her. But then I looked around at the same faces in the same places, recalled all that was promised and especially all that wasn’t delivered. Then, quite coincidentally, we arrived outside the White House right when House Republicans gathered there to celebrate the passage of their phony “repeal” of Obamacare. Their spin was repulsive, especially since most of the horrendous law remains intact. That’s when I finally realized … we didn’t change a thing, except ourselves. Republicans have long campaigned upon promises to limit the growth of government, decrease spending, lower taxes, and eliminate the debt, along with a host of other social issues, like protecting the unborn. Republican leaders said they needed the House to get these things done. Conservatives gave it to them, and with a historic majority. Next they told us they needed the Senate.…