Huntsville’s ban on book learning will backfire

Ray Bradbury ain’t got nothing on Huntsville’s government schools.

Sure, the author may have imagined a dystopian future in which books were abolished in Fahrenheit 451, but this school system in north Alabama is actually pulling it off.

And now it’s getting worse.

After switching from physical books to a laptop-only education a few years ago, some textbooks were allowed to remain in classrooms to ease the transition. They were helpful to those who still wanted real books, and they proved invaluable when the network went down, as networks are wont to do.

But now the school superintendent has told teachers they must scour their classrooms and collect all remaining physical textbooks – those contemptible relics of a bygone era – and hand them over to the authorities administration.

The firemen of Bradbury’s nightmare would approve. “A book is a loaded gun in the house next door,” said the fire chief in Fahrenheit 451. “Who knows who might be the target of the well-read man?”

No more pencils. No more books. No more teachers … well, teaching. Because once the curriculum, the materials, the tests, the schedule, and everything else are sucked into some giant standardized network, our teachers become more like facilitators of a program than educators of children.

Transformations like those in Huntsville aren’t without serious critics. Paul Thomas, a teacher and professor of education who authored a dozen books about educational methods, told the New York Times “a spare approach to technology in the classroom will always benefit learning.”

“Teaching is a human experience,” he said. “Technology is a distraction when we need literacy, numeracy and critical thinking.”

Some of the brightest minds in computer science agree. There’s even a low-tech school in Silicon Valley where the tech wizards of Apple and Google send their children. No computers can be found there until high school, only pens, paper, and real books.

Others will defend Huntsville’s move by pointing to the fact that the texts – the actual words – remain, but only in digital format. That’s only partly true. The words are still there, but their effect and the results are certainly different. There’s a great deal of discussion on the issue, from researchers claiming that children learn better from printed material, to studies showing large doses of screen-time during childhood causes learning problems, to people being able to more accurately recall material read from a page rather than a screen.

These are real issues that should cause everyone to stop and reevaluate the all-screens-no-pages approach, but older generations still cling to dreams that computers will solve all our problems. Parents seem to demand it, too.

This is further complicated because when modern leaders encounter challenges, some first look for computer-based solutions rather than relying on their people. If complex algorithms are involved, it must be better than whatever some guy down the hall could attempt, they think.

It’s a cheap trick, though. A false promise. It’s the traveller who takes a short cut through a treacherous swamp rather than expend the effort needed to walk the long, winding, yet ultimately safe road.

And when results aren’t worth talking about, high tech decorations serve as helpful distractions. We rarely hear about improvements to grades, test scores, or graduation rates in Huntsville’s schools, but they’ve never failed to remind us that every student has a laptop.

Handing a student a computer is an activity, not a result. We could have hired BestBuy to operate our schools if all we wanted was more technology. But we’re looking for something else, something a bit more elusive, challenging, and I guess old fashioned: learning.

If we have any effort and expense to spare, it should be directed to giving teachers better pay, more freedom in their classrooms, and the opportunity to teach in the tried and proven methods of generations past.

Years from now, when these laptop-educated children are parents themselves, and teachers and principals and even superintendents, they’ll look back on Huntsville’s experiment with great disappointment.

“What were they thinking,” they’ll wonder, “shoving these laptops in front of our eyes all day, as if we needed more screens and less books in our lives.”

Allow me to provide the future with our answer: We’re not thinking. Not at all.

24 thoughts on “Huntsville’s ban on book learning will backfire

  1. 醫學美容 磨皮 cosmetic.wiki

    【保養】毛孔清潔好伙伴 ✿林三益潔淨煥顏套裝 – Katerina的花俏部落格 •Beauty •Fashion •Lifestyle 【保養】毛孔清潔好伙伴 ✿林三益潔淨煥顏套裝, Katerina的花俏部落格 •Beauty •Fashion •Lifestyle: 【保養】毛孔清潔好伙伴 ✿林三益潔淨煥顏套裝, Katerina的花俏部落格 •Beauty •Fashion •Lifestyle

  2. 醫學美容-日系-牛乳-cosmetic-wiki

    比仰卧起坐更有效!捲腹要這樣做才能練出人魚線 Marie Claire (HK) Edition 仰卧起坐可以說是中學體育堂的基本動作,相信大家對這個動作都不陌生。但假如想在短時間内減肚腩練出人魚線,就要靠做捲腹了。捲腹(Crunch) 是一個訓練上腹肌的練習,姿勢跟仰卧起坐相似,但效用

  3. 醫學美容-高效-氧氣-cosmetic-wiki

    Rene Furterer 荷那法蕊 【MELALEUCA白千層抗屑系列】MELALEUCA白千層油性抗屑髮浴 Melaleuca anti-dandruff Shampoo for oil的商品介紹 Rene Furterer 荷那法蕊,MELALEUCA白千層抗屑系列,MELALEUCA白千層油性抗屑髮浴 Melaleuca anti-dandruff Shampoo for oil

  4. Football Solutions Daniel Lafferty

    Michael Carrick has been named as Manchester United’s new captain following the departure of Wayne Rooney to Everton. He becomes the club’s eighth skipper of the Premier League era. Manchester United have named Michael Carrick as their new captain… but will he have the same success as former skippers such as Eric Cantona, Roy Keane and Wayne Rooney?

  5. curry 4

    Thanks a lot for giving everyone an extremely superb chance to discover important secrets from here. It’s usually very pleasing and packed with a good time for me personally and my office mates to search your blog a minimum of thrice in one week to learn the new items you have got. And definitely, I’m so always pleased with your breathtaking pointers you serve. Certain 2 tips on this page are indeed the most impressive we have ever had.

  6. adidas ultra boost 3.0

    Thanks so much for giving everyone an extraordinarily nice chance to read critical reviews from this site. It really is very good and also jam-packed with a great time for me and my office acquaintances to visit your site more than 3 times a week to find out the fresh tips you have got. Not to mention, I’m at all times happy with the unbelievable tips and hints you give. Some 1 points in this posting are easily the most impressive we’ve ever had.

  7. jordan 1 off white

    I needed to write you this very little word in order to thank you the moment again considering the awesome solutions you have shared on this website. This has been certainly strangely open-handed with people like you to present unreservedly what a lot of folks could possibly have advertised as an e book in order to make some money for their own end, most importantly considering that you could have tried it in the event you considered necessary. Those tricks additionally worked to become easy way to be sure that other people online have similar eagerness the same as my very own to figure out very much more with reference to this condition. I believe there are lots of more pleasant occasions in the future for those who browse through your site.

  8. yeezy shoes

    Thanks a lot for providing individuals with an extraordinarily spectacular chance to read articles and blog posts from this website. It is usually so good and as well , packed with a good time for me and my office mates to visit your blog minimum 3 times per week to read the new things you have got. Of course, we are actually pleased with your wonderful techniques you give. Some two points in this article are indeed the most effective we have all ever had.

  9. adidas nmd

    I would like to convey my love for your kind-heartedness in support of those who require help on that concern. Your personal dedication to getting the solution all over has been especially useful and have always helped guys just like me to get to their desired goals. Your amazing helpful key points entails this much a person like me and even further to my fellow workers. Regards; from all of us.

  10. adidas eqt

    Thank you for every one of your effort on this website. Gloria takes pleasure in carrying out investigation and it is obvious why. My spouse and i hear all relating to the compelling medium you offer powerful secrets through this web blog and as well as cause participation from other individuals on this article then our child is truly becoming educated a lot. Have fun with the remaining portion of the year. Your performing a very good job.

  11. goyard

    I precisely needed to thank you so much once again. I do not know the things that I would have done without the type of tactics discussed by you relating to such industry. It absolutely was the frightful matter in my view, but viewing the very expert strategy you managed the issue forced me to cry over happiness. I’m happy for this assistance as well as have high hopes you find out what an amazing job you have been putting in instructing the mediocre ones by way of your web site. Probably you have never encountered any of us.

  12. michael kors outlet online

    I simply desired to thank you so much yet again. I do not know the things I could possibly have created without those advice shared by you about such subject. Entirely was a frustrating difficulty in my circumstances, nevertheless finding out a skilled avenue you handled it took me to leap for joy. I’m just happy for the guidance and even have high hopes you realize what a great job you’re accomplishing teaching the mediocre ones via your blog post. Most likely you have never encountered all of us.

  13. yeezy boost 350

    I actually wanted to write down a simple remark in order to say thanks to you for those nice items you are posting on this website. My considerable internet search has now been compensated with really good strategies to go over with my companions. I would believe that many of us visitors actually are really endowed to be in a remarkable place with very many wonderful individuals with valuable tactics. I feel extremely blessed to have encountered the webpage and look forward to many more awesome times reading here. Thanks a lot once again for everything.

  14. nike air max

    I would like to express my thanks to this writer just for rescuing me from this particular circumstance. As a result of browsing through the search engines and finding recommendations which are not productive, I was thinking my life was well over. Being alive devoid of the answers to the issues you’ve solved by means of your good article is a critical case, and ones which could have negatively affected my career if I had not noticed your website. The knowledge and kindness in taking care of all areas was invaluable. I’m not sure what I would’ve done if I hadn’t come across such a thing like this. I can also at this point relish my future. Thank you so much for your expert and amazing guide. I will not think twice to refer your web blog to any person who requires recommendations about this situation.

  15. retro jordans

    I wanted to create you the bit of remark to say thanks the moment again about the unique secrets you have shared at this time. It is certainly seriously open-handed of people like you to give without restraint just what a lot of people might have made available for an e book to get some cash for themselves, precisely now that you could possibly have done it in case you considered necessary. These strategies likewise worked like the good way to understand that someone else have the same interest like my personal own to figure out a good deal more when it comes to this matter. I think there are several more pleasurable situations in the future for many who check out your blog post.

  16. golden goose outlet

    I would like to show my passion for your kindness supporting individuals that absolutely need help with this important niche. Your real commitment to passing the solution up and down came to be remarkably effective and has empowered regular people just like me to achieve their dreams. Your informative tips and hints indicates much to me and especially to my colleagues. Warm regards; from all of us.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.