Memo to Gov. Warner: Sixty-Five Spells Defeat

* Originally published in the American Spectator on October 12, 2004.

Virginia Gov. Mark Warner evoked the Deep South last week to rationalize his $1 billion tax increase, saying that if low-taxes were the “criteria for success” then “Alabama and Mississippi would be leading the nation.” I’ll gladly offer the governor some advice.
First, he could’ve looked straight across his Northern boundary for a more familiar cause-and-affect example of taxation. If high-taxes alone were the criteria for success, there’d be an exodus of his constituents across the Potomac River into Washington, D.C., where per-pupil spending is the highest in the nation and nearly every tax is higher. So, what’s Washington leading the nation in right now? Terrible schools for starters, but murder and urban blight are always close seconds.However, if Warner would like a relevant example from Alabama, here’s a whopper: we just rejected our own billion-dollar tax increase by a 2-1 margin, and Virginia might concur if a photograph in last week’s Washington Post reveals Warner’s strategy. The picture was of the governor standing beside a poster board upon which he had just written, “65% Pay Less.”
“If there’s one thing I want you to remember,” Warner said to a crowd who had gathered to hear his pitch, “it’s that at the end of this plan, 65 percent of Virginians will pay less.”
I’ve never seen a number spell a word, but 65 certainly spells “defeat.”
Proponents of Alabama’s tax increase also relied heavily on the notion of further shifting the cost of government from the many to the few. They repeated a strikingly similar phrase: “70 percent of Alabamians will pay less.” The political experts were left scratching their heads when nearly that many voted against the plan. The reason is clear: the phrase “tax increase” isn’t some variable expression open to interpretation. The average worker knows that when you take five thousand dollars from a rich man, you take five dollars from the poor man he employs. So despite the cleverness of political advertising, it’s impossible to convince Americans they’ll pay less when a tax increase is described by the word “billion.” Besides, they’ll call you a liar and your authority will plummet.
The Democrat governor then told the crowd about several scenarios where most taxpayers would pay such-and-such less and get this-or-that in return. Warner is gambling that most Virginians will gladly shrug their tax burden onto the “rich,” and thus demand his plan’s approval from their GOP-dominated legislature. (Alabama’s increase failed a statewide vote, an arguably easier path than asking a group of conservative lawmakers for final approval).
Yet those poised to pay less under the Alabama plan — Warner’s golden 65 percent — were the same people who voted it down. The experts were further perplexed, but the reason remains clear: a poor man can plainly calculate what five bucks less every payday means to his life. The rich, and even the middle class, often cannot. They’ve got a bit of a cushion. What’s five bucks, right? Plenty on the other side of the tracks, but few political experts know anything about that.
Like Warner, I’ve paid taxes in Northern Virginia, but also in Washington, Alabama and a few other places I’d rather forget, and can testify that increasing taxes doesn’t increase a community’s quality of life, on either side of the tracks. Taxes actually have very little to do with measuring a community, other than providing numbers to diagram against the numbers of some other place.
Virginia is doing rather well, and siphoning capital from its economy would do nothing but harm. It’s the quality of people, not government, and certainly not how much government takes from the people, that determines a community’s quality of life and its overall success. And in those respects, Gov. Warner, Alabama and Mississippi are leading the nation.

16 thoughts on “Memo to Gov. Warner: Sixty-Five Spells Defeat

  1. Herb Stambach

    Excellent goods from you, man. I’ve take into account your stuff previous to and you’re simply extremely magnificent. I really like what you have got right here, really like what you are stating and the best way in which you say it. You are making it entertaining and you continue to take care of to stay it wise. I can not wait to read far more from you. This is really a great website.

  2. 醫學美容 雪映

    真防水!輕巧喇叭 野餐、行山靠曬佢 Marie Claire (HK) Edition 關於音響器材,老實說小編完全一曉不通,但對於Bose這個牌子還是略有認知,特別是Bose推出了全新SoundLink Micro藍牙揚聲器後,更直頭令我產生興趣,因為實在太方便! 話說小編一向走

  3. 腋下止汗

    CLINIQUE 倩碧線上購物官網。瀏覽Clinique倩碧官方網站,了解更多線上購物、護膚、彩粧、香氛及禮品詳情。通過過敏性測試,百分百不含香料。

  4. 醫學美容 醫學美容

    12時辰養生時間表逐個睇 較啱時間飲水原來好過食補品!Healthcare 保健養生SundayMore 都市人經常食不定時,但為了令身體更健康,我們應該規律生活,令每個腑臟都能適時有效地排出毒素,跟住這個12時辰養生時間表去養生就對了!

  5. 醫學美容 Laser facial

    來自瑞士的Teosyal®透明質酸,是由世界第三大以透明質酸為基礎的TEOXANE藥廠研發。Teosyal ®Redensity II® 是專門為眼部肌膚而設計的透明質酸。屬於半鏈結透明質酸的Redensity II® ,輕微吸濕力可減少水腫。 半鏈結透明質酸的柔軟度較高,於注射之後不會產主粒狀問題。可撫平中度皺紋,主要用於淚溝、額紋、手部填充、木偶紋、豐唇、耳珠、太陽穴、人中、面頰填充、虎紋

  6. 醫學美容-三角褲-私密-cosmetic-wiki

    Try me to be Beauty崔咪’s懶人內彎頭髮整理術 @ B2B崔咪TRAMY :: 痞客邦 :: 冷冷的冬天已經來到,台北濕冷的天氣真的很令人受不了呢~大家要穿多一點不要感冒喔~冷呼呼的只想躲在被窩裡阿 呵呵對了~如果喜歡崔咪平常穿搭的朋友可以觀看這本相簿:mix and match(直接點選即可

  7. Football Solutions Lisa Dahlkvist

    MATT LAWTON: Teddy Sheringham has emerged as a shock contender for the role of forwards coach at West Ham. Sam Allardyce has been told to introduce a more attacking brand of football if he wants to remain as manager, with the recruitment of a more offensive coach part of the deal. Teddy Sheringham set to join Sam Allardyce as new West Ham attacking coach

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.